Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Carrok's commentslogin

This was true, but today I would much rather have an llm categorize my expenses. Me doing it manually will never happen.

That’s fair — and I agree if enough context exists.

The key limitation is that a raw bank transaction usually contains very little semantic information: amount, merchant name, date. From that alone, an LLM can only guess based on patterns or prior behavior, not actually know what the expense was for.

“$100 at a supermarket” could be groceries, pet food, a household item, or something work-related. An LLM can infer probabilities once it has enough historical data and feedback, but that still means the user has to correct or confirm things at some point.

So I see LLMs as very helpful for assisting categorization (suggestions, defaults, learning over time), but they can’t fully replace intent unless the underlying data becomes richer than what bank statements provide today.


Why not build a receipt scanner then?

Is there any chance it could become richer? What governs the content of credit card and bank statements? Is there anyone pushing for them to be more useful?

I think (granted, this is from a quick bit of research so I could be wildly wrong) - the message you see in your credit card app with a transaction is usually mainly the merchant name and location which is part of ISO 8583, so it may be a bit hard to extend it to include an arbitrary message in a way that works without merchants having to replace card reader/POS systems en-masse.


Oh no. Raw AppleScript in a Swift program. Don’t people know stuff anymore? I’m especially disappointed since it’s coming from Steipete…

Anyways, that’s how you do AppleScript in Swift (it’s even type-safe!) [1]

Usage example. [2]

[1] https://github.com/Frizlab/apple-music-to-slack/blob/90964bb...

[2] https://github.com/Frizlab/apple-music-to-slack/blob/90964bb...


> Don't people know stuff anymore?

No, no one has ever known anything, and every day people are born knowing even less. This is a strangely aggressive way to share this interesting information, especially for MacOS programming, a platform requiring such byzantine arcane knowledge I'm amazed people write anything for it at all. At least for Win32 people wrote books you could buy and not blog posts.

Anyway, thank you for the introduction to the very cool SwiftScripting project [0], extracting programmable interfaces directly from app bundles. It's just like COM, right? nice to see MacOS catching up (/ragebait)

[0] https://majestysoftware.wordpress.com/2015/03/31/swift-scrip...


AppleScript: First appeared 1993.

COM: First appeared 1993.

Yup. Catching up.

I understand the rage, but get your facts right.

Also, FYI the interesting part about the post is getting the extracted code in type-safe Swift code. Getting the extracted code for ObjC is trivial and any seasoned macOS developer should already know how to do it.


If you have your PayPal creds in your repository, you are doing it wrong.


.gitignore is a thing


Which every AI tool I’m aware of respects and ignores by default.


Why is it that they can add new env variables then?


It is trivial to append to files without reading them. Also, no AI provider even wants your secrets, they are a liability. Do whatever you want though, I'm not here to convince you of anything.


This is probably different between startups and enterprises. My background is purely startups, and I can't imagine not having access to 100% of the code for the company I work.


From the linked press release (https://www.sgpc.gov.sg/detail?url=/media_releases/astar/pre...)

> Among children whose parents read to them frequently at age three, the link between infant screen time and altered brain development was significantly weakened.

It sounds a bit like the problem might not be so much "heavy screen time" as "heavy screen time, plus no alternative stimulation". Not defending heavy screen time at all, just thought it was an interesting tidbit.


Knowing little about the research, my prior would be that screen time is bad for kids and is also a proxy measure for the attentiveness of parents


I would tend to agree with that. I can even see in my own kids changes in behavior when external factors affect my own ability to be attentive to my kids.


Could also be that reading helps with parent bind somehow

I could see some sort of real world grounding helping reduce anxiety



I've used one for years now. No issues. Not sure what you're worried about.


Many ways. Using a "bastion host" is one option, with something like wireguard or tinc. Tailscale and similar services are another option. Tor is yet another option.


The bastion host is a server, though, and would be exposed to the internet.


It can run a firewall and forward to internal traffic as well.


>Never expose your server IP directly to the internet, vps or baremetal.


This will almost certainly be used by people to sanity check their HN submissions before actually submitting, very similar to having AI review your branch before submitting a PR.

Here is what it has to say about itself: https://news.ysimulator.run/item/113


top comment checks out

> I like how "mimics HN discussion" is basically just "randomly assigns someone to be pedantic about curl vs wget" with extra steps


bahah


Or like Nathan Fielder's The Rehearsal show on HBO Max. Also, the show's subreddit has a companion subreddit for posting to before you post to the real one.


A friend of mine was speculating about the same thing. I'm totally happy with it just existing as a toy, but if it serves some useful purpose, even better!


I love that this very point is in fact one that it generated against itself!

https://news.ysimulator.run/item/336

Spooky…


Really spooky, all comments are LLM based and something certainly feels off, but can't quite put my finger on what it is.

I think it has to do with comments that doesnt really comment on the previous comment.

Certainly one of the more interesting uses of LLMs in a while.


Not to be confused with the other grid based light flipping game, Lights Out, from 1995.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lights_Out_(game)

Math article https://matroidunion.org/?p=2160


Or 80s Merlin’s Magic square game.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merlin_(console)

Which was only 3x3. But red LEDs which were all the rage in handhelds in the 80s.

When learning JavaScript I made a dupe of the Merlin game in JavaScript. It’s really old but still seems to run. Lacks the depth of this game with its larger grid.

https://www.aramcomjean.com/magic_squares.html


Amazing. I had one of these, and playing your version just took me back to the frustration I had figuring out that game when I was 7 years old.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: